New URL for the American Idol buzz blog!
Please go to the new American Idol Buzz blog at http://blogs.ajc.com/american-idol-blog/
Access Atlanta > American Idol Buzz > Archives > 2008 > April > 29 > Entry
4/29: Top 5 Idol performance night with Neil Diamond & Paula’s (ahem) confusion
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
(For you live bloggers, sorry, I was out late tonight and only got around to posting my thoughts at about midnight.)
Neil Diamond is not going to bring in that younger audience “Idol’ is losing, but he sure has written some great songs over the years. And thank God nobody chose his cheesiest song, the ode to “E.T.” “Heartlight.” Then again, check out “America,” courtesy of David Archuleta, trying to pull another Kristy Lee Cook (as if he needs it!)
In the end, it was a pretty scattershot night. There were more than a fair share of clunkers for this point in the competition, a couple of great performances and more proof that David Cook should take this home for consistency, professionalism and vocal skills. Sorry, Archuleta!
Who will be in trouble? Well, Archuleta is fine as usual. I’m not sure at this stage if they even do a bottom three. If it’s just a bottom two, I’d say Jason and Syesha. Jason is going home is my guess only because Syesha was lucky enough to get the pimp spot, even if it was a disappointing final performance.
Dialidol actually has Syesha in the safe zone! You have to wonder if Simon’s comments about her being in trouble helped her, especially since he said them moments before voting started. Jason, Brooke and David A. are in danger.
And let me explain poor Paula Abdul’s belief that Jason sang twice already during the halfway point. (SEE VIDEO) The thing is—she and the others watched the dress rehearsal, where she had seen both performances and had, paraphrasing Ryan, “seen the future.” Then she got confused during the actual performance show. This is no proof that “Idol” is rigged or her comments are scripted. She simply can’t remember what happened 15 minutes earlier versus two hours earlier! In other words, vintage Paula. But very amusing!
I suspect Simon spends a lot of time gabbing with Paula during the actual performances since they had already heard them during dress. That’s also possibly why, if a contestant did great in rehearsal and bombed during the live show or vice versa, the judges’ comments seem way way off. Paula should have immediately explained herself and said she had heard Jason sing earlier during dress. That would have helped 99.9% of the audience watching that has no clue this is the case.
Anyway, at this stage, order of performance probably is less meaningful now that each contestant has to sing twice, especially going first.
So this time, I will rank the 10 performances in order, rather than post them in order. I’ll include judge’s comments when available since they only really talked after the second song (not counting that strange mid-time interlude when Paula’s brain went haywire.)
1-David Cook (“All I Really Need is You”) - Honestly, at this point, it’s hard not to root for Cook to win because he infuses every song with heart. Even if this wasn’t as stellar a vocal performance as usual, his emotional compass keeps everything in check and makes it worth listening to. Randy: “Again, you rocked the house!” Paula: “I feel like I’m already looking at the American Idol.” Simon: “I thought the first song was okay, the second song brilliant.” (seventh performance) A/A-minus
2-Brooke White (“I Am I Said”) - She personalizes the lyrics to Arizona, courtesy of Neil’s suggestion. This is more like it, a song that fits her. Sure, as usual, her vocals are just okay but this is the Brooke we love. I really wanted to hear a longer version, a good sign. Randy: “Nice job.” Paula: “What you did as opposed to the first song. It shows your vulnerability and it works.” Simon: “I really really hated the first song. It was like girls’ night out for karaoke. This is the Brooke we like. It wasn’t incredible but a million times better than the first song. Well done.” (eighth performance) A-minus
3-Syesha Mercado (“Hello Again”) - She does a drop-dead gorgeous version of this rather pensive song, though her big smile doesn’t seem to jibe. I enjoyed it. (fifth performance) A-minus.
4- Jason Castro (“Forever in Blue Jeans”) - This is a nice laid-back song that fits Castro well. He seems more comfortable than he was last week. (Is it just me or is the mosh pit looking a bit thin tonight?). Vocally, the song isn’t much of a strain for him and he imprints it with that Castro vibe and it works well. (First performance) B-plus/A-minus
5-David Cook (“I’m Alive”) - He opted for two lesser-known songs, which is not a bad idea. (Second performance) He’s comfortable and luxuriates in his lower register with a professional sheen that includes just a hint of that Diamond growl. Another solid performance, nothing to complain about. (Second performance) B-plus
6-David Archuleta (“Sweet Caroline”) - David took Carly’s song. He starts the song in a higher key than Neil. In fact, the whole arrangement barely sounds like the original, which is sometimes good, sometimes not so good. This time: not so good. The problem is he really isn’t very good at upbeat (see Brooke White). He even hits a few bad notes. He ends okay, at least, but this won’t win him any new fans. (fourth performance) B-minus
7-Pimp spot! Syesha Mercado (“Thank God for the Night Time”) - Her vocals feel a bit mannered and Broadway for a song that could have used a bit more vocal grit. The actress in Syesha is very much in effect. It feels very staged. Randy: “You finally realize who you are. Could have been on Broadway.” Paula: “First song I thought that vulnerable side is absolutely beautiful. That’s your magic. Your second song shows your other side. That’s your theatrical side.” (She said she’s a cross of Corinne Bailey Rae and Minnie Ripperton.) Simon: “It’s a bit chaotic tonight. You demonstrated again. You’re a good actress -stroke- singer. I think however you may be in trouble tonight. It wasn’t a memorable second song like the others.” [I agree.] (10th performance) B-minus
8-David Archuleta (“America”) - Big mistake picking one of Neil’s cheesier songs and another upbeat song. He lacks the gravitas that makes this work with Neil. It feels lightweight. But hey, it’s patriotic and he gets to hit a final grace note with “let freedom ring” while an American flag plays behind you. Randy: “You are in the zone. Another great performance, baby.” (huh?) Paula: “This was the absolute perfect song for you to sing.” (wah?) Simon: “That was a smart choice of song.. that was clever. It ticked all the boxes.” (ninth performance ) B-minus
9-Brooke White (“I’m a Believer”) - This song requires a really strong voice and she simply doesn’t have it. When she bugs her eyes out, she looks fairly absurd. Why is Paula up there dancing? It’s weak but you gotta give her credit for trying something outside her norm. (third performance) C-plus
10-Jason Castro (“September Morn”) - Paula already said she wasn’t feeling this one (from the dress rehearsal.) Maybe the advance criticism will help him. It’s actually just kinda boring. He does it in really sleepy AC style. His voice sounds lazy and the entire thing feels phoned in. Bleh. Randy: “It was just okay.” Paula: “I felt safe. You need to get out of the comfort zone.” Simon: “We don’t recognize you at the moment. There was no attempt to make the songs your own. They were both forgettable.” (sixth peformance) C
In other “Idol” news:
-The EW power five shows minor shifts with David C. remaining at No.1, David A. back at No. 2, Jason dropping to No. 3, Brooke taking Carly’s spot at No. 4 and Syesha taking Brooke’s spot at No. 5. TV Guide had them ranked the same order with votes as follows: 55.8% for David Cook. 20.9% David Archuleta. 12.7% Jason Castro. 6.7% Brooke White. 3.8% Syesha Mercado. Gambling sites have Archuleta winning, with Cook a close second. The other three are also rans with Jason at 15-1 and both Brooke and Syesha at 20 to 1.
-Michael Johns told an Australian pub how surreal it was to be at the White House Correspondents Dinner this past Saturday.: “Condoleezza Rice came up and hugged me, asked to take a picture and have an autograph,” Johns told Confidential yesterday. “Rob Lowe demanded a recount, everyone thinks I was robbed.”
-I have a spare copy of Phil Stacey’s new CD if anybody wants it. Email me at rho@ajc.com. It comes out today!
-The Ruben/Frenchie Davis take on “Ain’t Misbehavin’” is scheduled to kick off its national tour Nov. 17, 2008 at the Fox Theatre.
-Paris Bennett is performing with her grandma Ann Nesby at the “Songs of Soul & Inspiration” concert at Philips Arena on my birthday, June 21. Patti Austin, Chaka Khan, Yolanda Adamas Queen Latifah and others are headlining.
-Carrie Ann Inaba, a judge on “Dancing With the Stars,” notes that Paula Abdul might have problems if she joins the show:
“She’s [emotionally] fragile. And she’s had physical issues [a neck injury]. She won’t even realize how much pressure is on her until she’s already signed up and can’t get out,” Inaba tells TV Guide magazine (May 5 issue; hits newsstands Thursday, May 1). “I would hate to see her get hurt by something she loves.”
Comments
By flats
April 29, 2008 4:12 PM | Link to this
FIRST!!!!WOOOOHOOOO!!!!!YEAH BABY!!!!!!!
By flats
April 29, 2008 4:15 PM | Link to this
I thank we should be able to wear panties without being made fun of.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 4:20 PM | Link to this
The following was posted on another site where game-playing is apparently important. Referring to Syesha’s choices. Take it as you will:
*I can’t reveal too much, but I know it to be one of these four combonations:
So based on that list, you tell me which combination you think is the one for her (I don’t know the exact one, only that it’s definitely one on this list.)
And BTW, my guess is either 2 or 4.*
By flats
April 29, 2008 4:26 PM | Link to this
Thanks D….Maybe she will go home this week..she’s so close every week!!!!
By qwerty
April 29, 2008 4:27 PM | Link to this
“Heartlight.” Ugh.
By rickster
April 29, 2008 4:28 PM | Link to this
My guess is #2, she won’t be able to resist “You Don’t Send Me Flowers”
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 4:40 PM | Link to this
I’m pretty sure it isn’t the third choice since I’m also pretty sure Jason is singing September Morn.
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 29, 2008 4:44 PM | Link to this
I just hope you’re right about one of DC’s songs…. gawd, would that be an emotional choice or WHAT!?
By flats
April 29, 2008 4:53 PM | Link to this
i wear the granny panties as shorts out by the pool!
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 4:59 PM | Link to this
I think, if they really are singing 2 Neil Diamond songs, I’m going to need a tall Grey Goose and tonic instead of my usual glass of water to get through this show tonight.
By JTesla
April 29, 2008 5:04 PM | Link to this
Deirdre, and hold the tonic.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 5:09 PM | Link to this
JT…don’t tempt me! :-)
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 29, 2008 5:20 PM | Link to this
now that sounds tempting, D … might be a good way to work off some of this allergy stuff!
hmmmmmmmm
By JTesla
April 29, 2008 5:29 PM | Link to this
The only thing that could be worse than 10 Neil Diamond songs would be listening to Brooke and Jason singing Neil Diamond songs. I’m going to follow Deirdre’s lead and have some Baileys, if that doesn’t do the trick I’ll start chugging mouth wash.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 5:50 PM | Link to this
Sorry guys the spoiler network is failing tonight. This is all I’ve got thanks to mj. Spoiler Alert
* Jason Castro - “Forever in Blue Jeans” and “September Morn” - Joan, the reliable EW popwatch spoiler (check comments) left this hint: “A teeny hint for you spoiler lovers: Jason always dons durable twill weave when taking a stroll at dawn, when the foliage is dismounting.” * David Archuleta - “I’m a Believer”, “America” not enough concrete info to go with these choices yet… * Brooke White - “I Am I Said” at the piano - via Idol Forums message board * Syesha Mercado - According to a poster at the Idol Forums, Syesha’s 2 songs are one of the picks below. I’d go with #2.“Heartlight (Theme from E.T.)” & “Open Wide These Prison Doors”
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 5:52 PM | Link to this
I knew as soon as I posted the half-hearted spoilers, the reall ones would come up and here they are: Spoiler Alert
* Jason Castro - “Forever in Blue Jeans” and “September Morn” - * David Archuleta - “Sweet Caroline” and “America” * Brooke White - “I Am … I Said” at the piano and “I’m a Believer” * Syesha Mercado - “Hello Again” & “Thank the Lord for the Night Time” * David Cook - “I’m Alive”, “All I Ever Really Need is You”By DawnH
April 29, 2008 5:53 PM | Link to this
Oh no, JT. Worse than 10 Neil Diamond songs would have been 10 Dolly Parton songs!
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 6:04 PM | Link to this
Hey, I hear Def Leppard is performing on DWTS tonight. I LOVE DEF LEPPARD! Is it true - does anyone know?
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 6:20 PM | Link to this
True Dawn….
Another celebrity is eliminated; Def Leppard performs, accompanied by Tony Dovolani, Karina Smirnoff, Louis van Amstel, Cheryl Burke, Mark Ballas and Anna Trebunskaya dancing a group Paso Doble.
By ,,,=^..^=,,, from home
April 29, 2008 6:50 PM | Link to this
This i HAVE to see…. Paso done to Def Leppard. WOW. LOL!!!
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 6:55 PM | Link to this
Have not a clue what Paso Doble is.
It sounds a little like “pass the doobie”
By emily
April 29, 2008 7:01 PM | Link to this
ok, so my thoughts on the spoilers. i’m a davidson alumni, and i swear, if he hurts “sweet caroline” there will be heck to pay!!!!!
otherwise, eh. i still can’t believe it’s seriously neil diamond week!
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 7:13 PM | Link to this
Justin…and the rest of us who like Syesha…will be happy to learn that she has the ‘pimp spot’ tonight. In other words, she is last.
By Songluvr
April 29, 2008 7:39 PM | Link to this
Dawn - Girl you crazy! I would SO rather hear Dolly Parton songs tonight ~again~ than ND’s!
D - Who’s going first?
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 7:48 PM | Link to this
I think Jason is first but don’t quote me. Not positive about that. It only seems fair though…I don’t think he’s ever been first.
By ,,,=^..^=,,, from home
April 29, 2008 7:57 PM | Link to this
Paso Doble is a very dramatic latin dance … often used by ice skaters also for long routines. if you didn’t watch any of DWTS it’s hard to explain, lol. but last year, Cameron’s “superman” routine was a paso.
By Songluvr
April 29, 2008 7:58 PM | Link to this
Jason Castro singing Neil Diamond. Ugh. Two times. UGH!
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:03 PM | Link to this
Seyesha looks very nice tonight.
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:09 PM | Link to this
UGH
By flats
April 29, 2008 8:12 PM | Link to this
LOL @ EAGLE!
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 8:17 PM | Link to this
Is Paula auditioning for DWTS again?
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:17 PM | Link to this
CLEAN UP…….AISLE 3
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:27 PM | Link to this
Seyesha wins round one!!!
By Jeff
April 29, 2008 8:32 PM | Link to this
Paula already had her notes typed out! She’s so doped up she doesn’t know what she’s saying! What a disaster!
By boots
April 29, 2008 8:34 PM | Link to this
Ground control to Major Paula??? OMG. Makes you wonder if the whole thing is scripted!? Seyesha did best and I am so sick of the dred-lock-dude. Enuf already…
By flats
April 29, 2008 8:34 PM | Link to this
Eagle..I’ll be in lagrange soon.
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:34 PM | Link to this
You are right Jeff. This show is becoming a joke!
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:38 PM | Link to this
When flats?
By Caligula
April 29, 2008 8:42 PM | Link to this
Paula is a train wreck. Such a liability to the show.
By flats
April 29, 2008 8:45 PM | Link to this
End of the month..visit for a couple of weeks.
By pasace
April 29, 2008 8:48 PM | Link to this
what a joke paula has no idea whats she is saying and the archoleta kid stunk and they say he was great lol how funny keep those viewers lol
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 8:49 PM | Link to this
Brooke must be medicated tonight.
By Angela
April 29, 2008 8:52 PM | Link to this
I love reading all your postings but this is the first time I’ve logged on. First, I think if Brook wins, the therapists will have to work with some of you instead of her (just kidding!). That said, after tonight, as far as I’m concerned, let’s get rid of Archie. I started out as a fan but he is getting on my last nerve.
By Tami
April 29, 2008 8:53 PM | Link to this
Yep…I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: Looks like after tonight it WILL be the two Davids in the finale. I love DC, but I fear DA will win but it will be “gift” in the long run if DC doesn’t win. I think Jason is “outta here!”
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:53 PM | Link to this
Kendra Wilkinson is in the audience….YUMMY
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 8:58 PM | Link to this
Hang around Angela. We can talk about how bad the show sucked tonight.
By Tami
April 29, 2008 8:59 PM | Link to this
Wow…Syesha tore it up tonight, though. I’m just slightly conflicted.
By Sammy D
April 29, 2008 8:59 PM | Link to this
Whew, I was reading a blog over at phillyburbs.com and these 2 guys said Paula Abdul should be thrown off American Idol. Yes, how come they let her come back and comment on the second half of the singers’ performances. If FOX allows her to remain as a judge am sure there will be future lawauits. C’mon, get wise execs, give her the boot! S D
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 9:06 PM | Link to this
I have David C and Seyesha in a tie tonight. None of the others matter to me at this point.
By Dennis Dodd
April 29, 2008 9:09 PM | Link to this
Finally, someone noticed the Paula Abdul catastrophe. Why did they let her judge the last half hour…that can’t be legal. If she isn’t kicked off the panel, I am sure, no, I am positive, that FOX will never hear the end of it, via these blogs and newsgroups, D D
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 9:12 PM | Link to this
My order: David C, Syesha, Archie, Brooke, then Jason. So, David C or Syesha will probably be going home this week! Paula is a bigger idiot than Ryan - WHAT WAS THAT! Did you hear the audience giggling? Archie was, umm, Archie. Did he even sing 2 different songs? Brooke and Jason… well, LOL.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 9:14 PM | Link to this
Well that was interesting!
First, some general comments. The absolute BEST part of the show tonight was the judges not speaking for a full 28 minutes!!!!!! THAT was delightful!
That being said….Paula jumped the shark tonight. When she started talking about Jason’s second song…. well, what can anyone say. She’s going to be explaining herself for months. I think we all know that she saw the dress rehearsal and was talking about that performance BUT, that was SO FAR over the top that it overshadowed the performances.
I’m going to list my preferences by each performance. In the next post……is that like when Ryan says…after the break? :-)
By boots
April 29, 2008 9:16 PM | Link to this
I went back and watched it twice to make sure, but Paula called Syesha “Brooke” during the second round of comments. Seriously, she needs to go in to detox or something. We could make her the receipiant of next year’s American Idol Gives Back donations - Clean-up Paula!
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 9:18 PM | Link to this
OK, Sammy and Dennis. I’m sorry to be so stupid, but I don’t understand the legal implications of Paula’s faux pax. Would someone explain it to me. I agree it was stupid and embarrasing, but what are the legal implications?
By Menana
April 29, 2008 9:21 PM | Link to this
Idol wasn’t so bad tonight, except for long hair Jason. Hopefully, since he was first, tomorrow he will be history. One can only hope. Thought the rest was good. Brooke was great on her last song, I am…I Said. Thought she really performed well tonight. Both Davids sounded good. Syesha rocked on her first round, not so good on the second. Bottom two: Jason and Syesha. I say Syesha b/c of her last performance. Has she always performed without her shoes or have I just missed it? For the last several weeks, she has not worn shoes. Just wondering about that.
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:22 PM | Link to this
So it’s true! Tonight proved it. Reality shows are never really reality. Paula proved that tonight with her prewritten notes for 1st and 2nd songs when Jason had only sung the first song. It doesn’t matter if they fire Paula or not…American Idol is busted. They decide far ahead who they want to win and try to persuade America to follow. Shame on them. No more validation for American Idol.
Actually, Jason is sincere and good. He is has charisma and talent. American Idol can’t truely stop who America wants.
By Mike S
April 29, 2008 9:23 PM | Link to this
Tonight was a perfect example of what can happen when the contestants have absolutely brilliant material to choose from. Niel Diamond is one of the greatest song writers of the last 50 years, and every thing he has written is melodic and listenable. 1. David Cook - I’m Alive - While there have been some outstanding performances already this season, this was the first time I thought to myself “I would buy a CD with this song on it”. This performance had #1 hit written all over it. Outstanding!
David Archuletta - America - Simon hit it on the head when he said this was a perfect song choice. David sang it brilliantly, and for the first time in a while I was feeling some love for Monchichi.
Syesha Mercado - Thank the Lord for the Nighttime - OK who else was getting a major Martha Reeves/Diana Ross vibe from this. Syesha has found her comfort zone. When she has fun and just sings she is brilliant. Hopefully the last couple weeks have taught her to stay away from the POWER songs and just let her beautiful voice entertain us.
Syesha Mercado - Hello Again - Another vocal masterpiece by this young lady. She is so wonderful when she just sings.
David Cook - All I Really Need is You - This was another excellent DC performance. Not amazing, but very very good.
Brooke White - I am, I said - Finally Brooke is back behind the piano and the whole Carly Simon/Carole King sweetheart I fell in love with is back. Very pleasant.
Jason Castro - Forever in Blue Jeans - This was a nice solid Jason performance. But as usual it was nothing spectacular, just nice easy listening background music.
David Archuletta - Sweet Caroline - Ok, Monchichi has a great voice, and he sounded great on this song, but I absolutely HATED the arrangement, and it ruined a good vocal performance.
Brooke White - I’m A Believer - KARAOKE with a capitol K.
Jason Castro - September Morn - ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ.. huh? What? it’s over? THANK GOD!
Overall ratings - David Cook, Syesha Mercado, David Archuletta, Brooke White, Jason Castro.
Who should go - Dread boy Jason. He has a nice voice, but c’mon he is not anywhere near the class of the rest of the field.
Who Will Go - Brooke most likely. Jason has all the “oh look at those dreamy eyes” brain dead morons voting for him, so I have to say I think Brooke may be in serious trouble. Although Simon was right, Syesha needs to worry for no other reason than the voting weakness she has shown all year.
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:23 PM | Link to this
So it’s true! Tonight proved it. Reality shows are never really reality. Paula proved that tonight with her prewritten notes for 1st and 2nd songs when Jason had only sung the first song. It doesn’t matter if they fire Paula or not…American Idol is busted. They decide far ahead who they want to win and try to persuade America to follow. Shame on them. No more validation for American Idol.
Actually, Jason is sincere and good. He has charisma and talent. American Idol can’t truely stop who America wants.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 9:25 PM | Link to this
One: David Cook All I Really Need is You. So good and he was so smart to pick a lesser known song.
Two: Syesha Thank the Lord for the Night Time. If this girl doesn’t make it to 3 place the the world has gone wacko…she has a much better voice than Brooke and Jason.
Three: David Cook, I’m Alive
Four: Syesha, Hello Again…this was SO pretty
Five: Archie, Coming to America…he pulled the Kristy Lee card but it doesn’t really matter one way or another…he could have sung the phone book and he’d still be in the finals.
Six: Archie, Sweet Carolina…again a very nice job…but here’s my problem with Archie…he’s got that soft voice….it’s foggy but not in a good way like Mel Torme or Ruben Studdard. I like his clear voice much better but he can only haul that out for the loud, high notes. He’s a nice kid and a good singer but…no!
Seven: Brooke, I Am..I Said. She did an almost decent job with this.
Eight: Jason, September Morn….In this case, the song carried him but he didn’t get it.
Nine: Jason, Forever in Blue Jeans..I HATE it when he does the squeaky voice….and look at him…he doesn’t care!!!!!
Ten: Brooke, I’m a Believer…she started this too low so she could hit the money notes at the end but the money notes were such a small part of the song that she ruined the rest of it…a disaster, IMO.
By Justin
April 29, 2008 9:28 PM | Link to this
AHHH!
I felt so rushed tonight it was unbelievable.
2nd song: boring, boring, boring. Unfortunately the little girlies will keep him in. Maaaaaan. It is totally his time to go. “I was choking in the beginning” So? I felt bad because he sounded sad but yanno what? even if you weren’t choked up, you were still bad.
2nd song: Fantastic. His best, vocally at least. All said, he zooms through.
2nd song: Sounded like all her others, but vocally it wasn’t bad. She’s just ok though…and the weird sounds her voice makes shows she doesn’t quite have the vocal strength.
2nd song: Better, but hm… I don’t know I guess it was ok. One thing I must say though is… that crack in his voice midway through, the judges didn’t point that out AT ALL. Now honestly, if Syesha did that, the judges would really call her out on it and you know it. Whatever.. he was good. Good needs to be great though, and great is where the other David is.
2nd song: Started out incredibly weak, but then she got into it and really showed power out of that thing. Mark my words please: the judges, esp. Simon, is WAAAAY too hard on this girl. She is so much better than 2 or 3 that are left. Please don’t fill the top 4 with both Brooke and Jason. Anyway, I liked this song and she showed personality again. As I’ve said all along, she’s really the only one who looks and acts like a star out there. I hope she moves on. And oh boy Simon’s famous words: Trouble tonight. That shows he really still wants Jason to stay. Shame.
So, dialidol has safety now for Syesha, yet, I think they’ll throw her in for old times sake (in the bottom 2 that is).
Other person in bottom 2, either Jason or Brooke…
going home: eh, don’t know, syesha :(
…1-866-43657-05 or 10 :)!
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 9:28 PM | Link to this
OK..before everyone starts screaming that Paula proved the show was fake….Paula obviously made notes from the dress rehearsal and then, either because she’s a total idiot or she’s even higher on a controlled substance than we EVER suspected, she FORGOT that the show was only half over.
By sb
April 29, 2008 9:30 PM | Link to this
I like to believe the best about people but I think Paula numbered the singers 1-5 and didn’t name them in her notes and Ryan rushed the judges so much she got confused. Also at the first of the show Ryan said the judges would save comments until after the 5 sang their 2nd song so being on live tv and being rushed and having to come up with a quick comment on all 5 for two songs would be confusing. And what “can’t be legal?”
By Justin
April 29, 2008 9:34 PM | Link to this
OH YEAH! Forgot to say Paula called Syesha Brooke..Paula- shame on you!
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:38 PM | Link to this
So what if your opinion is quote “brain dead morons voting for him” speaking of Jason…he is actually a good person…you can see it in his eyes… and talented and draws people in. Brook has the look of a mean streak and the look of being controlling…you can see that in her eyes. Charisma does have something to do with wanting to see someone on stage when they perform…
By sb
April 29, 2008 9:38 PM | Link to this
Also I think Paula made notes during the show…not pre-written. Why do we have to make judgments? David A. didn’t get the lyrics right on the first song and no one said anything. Neil Diamond is a great singer/songwriter and still handsome and romantic as ever.
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 9:41 PM | Link to this
It’s a little sad when we have 5 contestants trying their best to be the next American Idol and all we can talk about is Paula’s screw up.
So I would like to say for the first time this season I enjoyed Seyesha.
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:42 PM | Link to this
So what if your opinion is quote “brain dead morons voting for him” speaking of Jason…he is actually a good person…you can see it in his eyes… and talented and draws people in. Brook has the look of a mean streak and the look of being controlling…you can see that in her eyes. Charisma does have something to do with wanting to see someone on stage when they perform…
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:42 PM | Link to this
So what if your opinion is quote “brain dead morons voting for him” speaking of Jason…he is actually a good person…you can see it in his eyes… and talented and draws people in. Brook has the look of a mean streak and the look of being controlling…you can see that in her eyes. Charisma does have something to do with wanting to see someone on stage when they perform…
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:44 PM | Link to this
So what if your opinion is quote “brain dead morons voting for him” speaking of Jason…he is actually a good person…you can see it in his eyes… and talented and draws people in. Brook has the look of a mean streak and the look of being controlling…you can see that in her eyes. Charisma does have something to do with wanting to see someone on stage when they perform…
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 9:45 PM | Link to this
karen…while I think the ‘brain dead morons’ was a cheap shot…I have to agree that Jason just doesn’t have the voice…and we’re not voting for nicest guy or best eyes, we’re voting for best singer…and he isn’t.
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 9:45 PM | Link to this
And earlier post were criticizing AI for spending to much time on Ryan and the judges. The exact same thing that is being done now by the same people that were complaining earlier.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 9:49 PM | Link to this
sb…I’m sure Paula is a nice lady and it was probably very smart of her to make notes on the performances during the dress rehearsal…however, she’s scattered, unfocused, easily distracted, and she totally messed up tonight. When you add that to all the other ‘little goofs’ that she’s made during the course of the show, it becomes a comedy of errors and makes her a laughing stock.
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:51 PM | Link to this
Sorry about the repeats…my computer was acting up!
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 9:52 PM | Link to this
WE - huh? AI didn’t give Ryan or the judges much play time tonight - thank goodness!
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 9:53 PM | Link to this
I’m glad you liked Syesha, WE! I thought she was terrific tonight and hope that she makes it to third place. She’s one of the few contestants who have steadily improved and who have obviously been learning something from the experience.
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 9:55 PM | Link to this
D - I don’t think you can use the words Paula and smart in the same sentence.
By karen
April 29, 2008 9:55 PM | Link to this
Sorry about the repeats…my computer was acting up! It wasn’t from dress rehersal. She showed what goes on or Simon wouldn’t have been so irrate.
By sb
April 29, 2008 9:57 PM | Link to this
Deirdre: I disagree completely. She’s talented, has a job on a popular tv show that I don’t think any of us have and I don’t think we should judge her for any reason.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 9:57 PM | Link to this
karen…it wasn’t your computer, it’s this antiquated blog format…it gets the hiccups!
By sb
April 29, 2008 9:58 PM | Link to this
Deirdre: I disagree completely. She’s talented, has a job on a popular tv show that I don’t think any of us have and I don’t think we should judge her for any reason.
By sb
April 29, 2008 9:58 PM | Link to this
Deirdre: I disagree completely. She’s talented, has a job on a popular tv show that I don’t think any of us have and I don’t think we should judge her for any reason.
By Justin
April 29, 2008 9:59 PM | Link to this
SYESHAS FIRST ON DIALIDOL!!!!!!!!!!!!
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 10:00 PM | Link to this
Brooke…..she’s as weak as Jason. Do y’all know that there are people out there voting for her based on the fact that they think she’s ‘sweet’!? What kind of reason is that!?
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 10:03 PM | Link to this
Congratulations Justin. You have worked hard for this moment!!
By mark
April 29, 2008 10:05 PM | Link to this
Just get rid of Paula and the show will improve.
I pretty much agree with everyone else. I thought David C and Syesha were the best followed closely by David A, whose act is wearing thin on me. Jason and Brooke were easily the worst and hopefully one of them will go. I’ll vote for Jason to leave because at least Brooke is trying.
By DawnH
April 29, 2008 10:06 PM | Link to this
I don’t think she is really sweet at all. She has shown us her “dark side” a couple of times. It’s a good act, though, and it is working.
By Songluvr
April 29, 2008 10:07 PM | Link to this
1- David Cook - All I Really Need is You. WOW!!!
2a- Syesha - Thank the Lord for the Night Time. Great job!
2b- David A. - Sweet Caroline - He finally displayed some of the energetic fun he’s been ripped for not having, and I thought the result was one of his best. It was not perfect, and therefore it was better than if it had been.
3a- David C. - I’m Alive - This guy is making me really like Neil Diamond songs. Who knew?
3b- Syesha - Hello - Just beautiful.
4- David A. - America - Very good, but less confident IMO because of the slight voice crack partway through.
5- Brooke - I Am, I Said - Neil Diamond music is so her.
6- Jason - Forever In Blue Jeans - Not his worst; not terrible.
7- Jason - September Morn - The obviousness of him not caring even managed to pi$$ Paula off.
8- Brooke - I’m a Believer - Excruciating.
By Harmony
April 29, 2008 10:13 PM | Link to this
Tonight was B-O-R-I-N-G
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 10:17 PM | Link to this
Worse than I was expecting Harm.
By Justin
April 29, 2008 10:18 PM | Link to this
Rodney, where are your comments?
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 10:18 PM | Link to this
LOL Dawn. I think she probably was smart to take notes early because she probably wouldn’t have been able to do it during the show. Unfortunately, it didn’t work out for her. :-)
By old fart
April 29, 2008 10:19 PM | Link to this
I’m a huge Neil Diamond fan from the start, hence the name. Based on tonight’s show only: 1. David Cook 2. Syesha Mercado 3. Brooke White 4. David Archuleta 5. Jason Castro
Granted America is too big to be done in 90 seconds but I’m sorry these songs demand emotion. Sweet Caroline needs something other than a choir boy. Jason chose safe but blah. He needs to go.
Paula needs a driver to Betty Ford.
By Harmony
April 29, 2008 10:21 PM | Link to this
Bad and rushed. BTW I know who the Hawks are playing now, Boston.
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 10:24 PM | Link to this
Anyone that calls their self “old fart” is good in my book.
By Justin
April 29, 2008 10:28 PM | Link to this
Forgot to post my rank!!
1 and 2. Syesha and David. Tied, just b/c one of their performances I liked better than their other, and they both shined tonight. Once again Syesha didn’t get the praise she so deserves.
David Archuleta- still a bit boring, i hope he can get past that.
Brooke White- just not good enough.
Jason Castro- Read above. Need I say more?
Clear bottom 2 shooooould be: Brooke and Jason…
Not quite sure who I want to go home, well yes, Jason, but it is interchangeable.
I want Brooke to go home, because I want Syesha to definitely be the top girl in this thing.
I want Jason to go home because I think it’d be harder for Brooke to make top 3 than it would for Jason, and I want Syesha there…! So hopefully Jason is outski.
Doubt it though…
And.. Though syesha is deservedly on top of dialidol, i’m sure the west coast will get cook and archuleta back above her…hence the reason they’ll throw her in the bottom 2 again.
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 10:34 PM | Link to this
old fart!!!! Welcome!!! I LOVE the name!
By Deirdre
April 29, 2008 10:39 PM | Link to this
I liked the show tonight. The focus was on the singers…not the judges…not Ryan. It may have been fast…it may have been rushed but it was ABOUT the singing!
By Negativo
April 29, 2008 10:45 PM | Link to this
Neg’s take:
1. David Cook: 8/10 on the first song, 9/10 on the second. Total points: 17.
He was again just awesome tonight, and shows why everyone else is playing for runner up. His grit combined with a touch of softness is a hard combo to beat, and I’m convinced he is the next American Idol.
2. Sayesha: 8/10 on the first, 9/10 on the second. Total points: 17.
She was awesome tonight, especially the second number where she had the backup singers on stage with her. Simon had nothing but bad things to say about her once again because apparently he doesn’t like her and wants her to go away. The rest of us who have a brain saw a girl who showed why she is here and Carly went home: she figured out how to sing pretty and strong but not over-reach beyond her range. If she goes home this week I will be seriously p** off.
3. Brooke: 3/10 first song, 7/10 second. Total points: 10.
First song was so bad I couldn’t decide if I was watching comedy or tragedy. Pitiful. 2nd song was good but not great.
4. Archuletta: 4/10 first song, 4/10 second. I think I finally know what I dislike about him most now: He is simply not a good singer or a good performer. He has no vocal range at all, is monotone, and offers nothing except little boy cuteness. His droning, irritating, breathy voice is hard on the ears and he just bounces around in place on stage with no emotion or clue at all. Double disaster.
5. Jason Castro: 4/10 first song, 3/10 second.
Q. How long can someone who can only whisper elevator music stay on idol? A. As long as idiot females under the age of 21 keep voting for him because he’s so dreamy. Just another sorry display, but still not as bad as his abysmal ukalele night from a month ago.
My prediction for bottom 2: Brooke and Sayesha. Going home: Sayesha.
Should be going home: Paula, for giving her opinion of Jason’s second song before he even friggin’ sang it! She should seriously be fired for that.
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 10:48 PM | Link to this
JT???????????????????
By Harmony
April 29, 2008 11:10 PM | Link to this
JT?????????????????
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 11:14 PM | Link to this
LOL Harm.
By Harmony
April 29, 2008 11:20 PM | Link to this
He still has not answered.
JT???????????????????????????????????
By War Eagle
April 29, 2008 11:33 PM | Link to this
JT is probably getting his groooove on.
It was Neil Diamond night.
By Harmony
April 29, 2008 11:44 PM | Link to this
DAVID COOK FOR THE WIN!!!!!!
By JTesla
April 30, 2008 12:21 AM | Link to this
Huh, what?
Just got done watching, it wasn’t as horrid as I thought it might be, well except for Brooke. Thanks for singing that Shrek song that is so overplayed that it causes me physical pain when I hear it. With that said I hope Jason goes, he just doesn’t care anymore as made plain by his stance when they were first standing on stage.
By Harmony
April 30, 2008 12:41 AM | Link to this
JT, I predict someone will be leaving idol again this week. Will the right one go? Who knows?
By Achin4Aiken
April 30, 2008 1:25 AM | Link to this
I will buy anything David Cook, Archie or Syesha record. I cannot imagine buying anything by Broke or Jason, and come on folks. There are folks in local kareoke lounges that sing and emote as well as he does. The guy is sub-talented. Broke is also a one-octave singer and will bore the tears off anyone’s face. Stop voting for these marginally talented people. You can’t watch a CD.
By JTesla
April 30, 2008 1:39 AM | Link to this
Yes Harmony it’s true: once again it is time to predict that someone will be leaving the show tomorrow night.
So what will next weeks theme be, I’m already tired of Mr. Diamond. Please split the songs as has been done in the past. I don’t want 8 of the same things.
By AL
April 30, 2008 6:32 AM | Link to this
Loved DC as usual; he is the only one of the contestants whose album I’ll buy. Brooke was better than last week with her second song, though that didn’t take much.
Simon assured Syesha of staying around with his comment about her being in danger of going home. That was very staged and apparently it worked if you look at the Dial Idol stats.
I think Brooke or Jason will go home.
By Joe
April 30, 2008 7:11 AM | Link to this
Well you are being waayyyy too nice to Paula. Aside from her being caught up with something else and not paying attention, Paula was INTOXICATED ! It was only a matter of time that she was so drunk, or jacked up on pills, that she would become totally out of touch with reality during a live show.
There has been talk about a change in “cast”,…. wouldn’t I be surprised if drunk Paula is watching Idol from her living room rext year.
By Joe
April 30, 2008 7:12 AM | Link to this
Well you are being waayyyy too nice to Paula. Aside from her being caught up with something else and not paying attention, Paula was INTOXICATED ! It was only a matter of time that she was so drunk, or jacked up on pills, that she would become totally out of touch with reality during a live show.
There has been talk about a change in “cast”,…. wouldn’t be surprised if drunk Paula is watching Idol from her living room rext year.
By Joe
April 30, 2008 7:14 AM | Link to this
Well you are being waayyyy too nice to Paula. Aside from her being caught up with something else and not paying attention, Paula was INTOXICATED ! It was only a matter of time that she was so drunk, or jacked up on pills, that she would become totally out of touch with reality during a live show.
There has been talk about a change in “cast”,…. wouldn’t be surprised if drunk Paula is watching Idol from her living room rext year.
By Joe
April 30, 2008 7:16 AM | Link to this
Well you are being waayyyy too nice to Paula. Aside from her being caught up with something else and not paying attention, Paula was INTOXICATED ! It was only a matter of time that she was so drunk, or jacked up on pills, that she would become totally out of touch with reality during a live show.
There has been talk about a change in “cast”,…. wouldn’t be surprised if drunk Paula is watching Idol from her living room rext year.
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 7:29 AM | Link to this
Morning mushblogians!
Dialidol is a sight to behold this morning. Not only do they have Syesha in 1st place but…Archie is listed as ‘in danger’!!!!!!
An obvious effort was made by the fans last night to save Syesha which tells me that the adults are starting to take over the zoo. Why Jason and Brooke are still standing while the likes of Carly, Michael and yes, Kristy Lee are sitting at home watching is beyond me.
For the first time this season, I’m hoping that dialidol got it absolutely right!
By Negativo
April 30, 2008 7:41 AM | Link to this
DialIdol cannot be trusted at all, D. They don’t count the text messages, of which 90% go to DA and none to Sayesha.
BTW, we for the first time all year voted repeatedly last night (for her and DC), so hopefully that’s a sign that grown ups are indeed starting to “take over the zoo”, as you stated.
One more thing. Sayesha deserves every vote she gets. She was leaps and bounds better than the putrid trio of Jason, Arch and Brooke.
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 7:50 AM | Link to this
Good for you, Neg and family! We should all be extending our efforts to make sure the right person wins.
At this point I’d love to see a Syesha/Cook finale(wishful thinking, I know) but I think I’ll just count myself happy if David Cook is the next American Idol
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 8:08 AM | Link to this
Good morning all! I’m at home today, waiting for the heating & air guys to get here to install new units - OUCH $$$. Please feel free to send in your donations! :)
Paula is obviously on something. Her behavior is at the very least awkward every show. What is with the jumping up and dancing - she reminds me of the Travelocity gnome. I think she is still trying to audition for DWTS. Which, by the way, I saw Def Leppard perform - I love Def Leppard! Of course, I love Neil Diamond too, so everyone ignore the gag reflex and stop laughing at me!
I don’t believe MJ should have gone; I don’t believe Carly should have gone. But I am still surprised that people are still saying Kristy Lee should still be there. Someone needs to explain her appeal to me (other than the obvious - duh). Her voice was just OK - not bad, not outstanding, and certainly Syesha and Carly were far better. She had no personality whatsoever, unless she was just insulting the judges after her performance. People are saying she would do well in country music. I love country music, and if she came on my radio, I would change the channel. I would certainly never buy a CD. I just don’t get it from a talent perspective.
I agree that for whatever reason Syesha can’t get a break from the judges. She is a good singer, and with the right song, a good performer. It doesn’t matter how well she does, it is alway unmemorable or just all right. Huh?
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 8:18 AM | Link to this
Good morning. I am so happy to read this morning that other folks reacted to Simon’s criticism of Syesha and voted multiple times for her. I did the same thing. I kept on voting until 11:00 PM, too. Of course, I always vote for DC, but it upset me to think that she might be in trouble, when Jason was so awful and might stay. Hopefully, you are all right about the adults taking over. I,for one, do not want to sit by and see another talented contestant go home, at the expense of a less talented one.
Did not think much of Neil Diamond’s mentoring. Maybe they cut out the “good” suggestions, but to me, he said almost the exact same thing about each contestant—unlike last week’s excellent ALW.
By ,,,=^..^=,,, from home
April 30, 2008 8:26 AM | Link to this
computer was down last night, i missed you guys!
David C and Syesha won the show last night imho. i liked BOTH sides of Syesha. Archie i found boring. Brooke i like the piano-playing carole king side of her, but she’s not star material, imho. i also like jason’s laid back persona, but again, just not star quality imho.
wish it could be a DC - Syesha finale, LOL wouldn’t that be a hoot.
running late! later!
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 8:34 AM | Link to this
Remember last week when Carly was eliminated…Simon apologized to her saying, “I gave you a compliment…it’s like the kiss of death”.?
Maybe Simon’s take on Syesha last night was an experiment to see if he could get us all voting for her. If it was…it worked.
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 8:40 AM | Link to this
D, it sure did for me. I have not been so energized about voting for a contestant in a long time. I was just determined that at least she would get my vote. Did not realize it affected all of you the same way. I sure hope it helped her stay around.
By flats
April 30, 2008 8:47 AM | Link to this
Good morning Mushdawgs!!!Seyesha,brooke,and jason should all go home!That was the worst display of so-called talent in idol history!
By flats
April 30, 2008 8:51 AM | Link to this
Brooke and David C in the final!!!!!Seyesha pack yo bags tonight!!!!Take j boy along for the ride!!!
By sharon
April 30, 2008 8:51 AM | Link to this
I’m starting to believe that David A’s family must have some blackmail material on the judges. He was so karaoke last night and yet they fell all over themselves praising him. He has a great voice but he lacks star appeal and everything he sings is starting to sound the same. Syeesha can’t catch a break. She was clearly the best in the first round but Simon said she was old fashion. What? these songs were out before she was born. After sitting through a lot of mess, he had the nerve to single her out and say she was in trouble. This show is such a joke. If she leaves tonight they will lose a lot of viewers because the only one left to hold anybodys interest is David Cook
By Lara
April 30, 2008 8:56 AM | Link to this
What a night. First off, the Paula incident. Well, they changed the format on her after how many years? Most people would be confused in that situation. Plus, we all know they watch dress rehearsals and make their comments based on those performances – how could she ever watch the real ones with Simon always touching her and talking to her? I feel like I have to defend her like a little puppy or something. Poor Paula.
Now, I didn’t take notes, and I am not going to rank them. What I will say is DAVID COOK RULES!!! I loved the comment that Simon made about him picking 2 very obscure Neil Diamond songs and making them current – they could be on the radio today. I think that may have been a little dig at Monchichi as he picked Mr. Diamond’s 2 most famous songs ever!!! YEAH!!!
Second to David, I think that Syeshia had a good night. But couldn’t she find a pair of shoes by her 2nd song? I still think she may lack one thing, with a beautiful voice, she still just doesn’t connect. I don’t think she knows whether she should look into the camera or into the audience. She seems a bit removed – just my opinion.
The other 3 are bringing up the bottom at the same rate for me. Brooke was just awful. She is really a one-trick pony. The girl cannot sing an upbeat song, and sure can’t perform without hiding behind an instrument. Just painful. Jason was just boring, man, I could fall asleep to that stuff! Someone should prescribe a Jason Castro cd to all those insomniacs!!! And boy did he end with a bad note on September Morn – I think he is giving up.
Now Archie really got on my nerves last night!!! The kid already annoyed me, and now I wish he would just go away. Sweet Caroline…come on now…and then Coming to America. I believe I had a discussion with someone the other day on how this song would be a great group sing – and this boy just had to pick it (using the Kristi Lee Cook card, maybe?). He changed the tunes, and not for the better – and boy, he hit some AGH notes as well. His performance was just way too cheesy for words (although I have used a lot here, I am sure someone will complain about the length of my post, hee hee). I really hope he is going home – or at least in the bottom 2 – he needs to get a little nervous!!
By Lara
April 30, 2008 9:01 AM | Link to this
Oh, and I voted for the 1st time this season last night. I called the 2nd # listed for David Cook over and over. I got through A LOT - what does that mean?
By flats
April 30, 2008 9:07 AM | Link to this
Lara…the judges are out to get Seyesha.She cant catch a break??????She made the freaken top 5 on the most popular show !!!
By Negativo
April 30, 2008 9:14 AM | Link to this
At this point any one of the 3-headed monster known as Castrobrookletta can go and I’ll be happy. I especially hate Arch and Castro’s styles because there is nothing, absolutely nothing, that they sing that I like. Zero. Brooke at least is pretty good on the piano sometimes, but they suck all the time.
Just keep DC and Sayesha alive this week and there will be no problems.
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 9:18 AM | Link to this
Flats - Syesha did make the top 5, but she did it with very little support from the judges (other than Paula saying she looks nice). Her performance is either not good, not memorable, or just OK. On the other hand, the judges treat Brooke, who consistently is sub-par, with kitt gloves. Of course, I am sure her delicate emotional state plays a part in that. She seemed OK last night - apparently the medication is working.
By flats
April 30, 2008 9:22 AM | Link to this
BRAVES????LOL!!!!!!!!!!!
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 9:25 AM | Link to this
I’m all for a Syesha/D.Cook finale! Do you honestly think we’ll be able to dethrone Archie!? I’m willing to give it a shot!
By flats
April 30, 2008 9:26 AM | Link to this
Dawn..Brooke and seyesha both suck.THis was supposed to be the best talent ever on idol?
By JTesla
April 30, 2008 9:40 AM | Link to this
When Simon made a comment last night regarding Syesha not making it, I was happy. I thought that it would motivate her fans, and maybe Simon thought that as well.
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 9:45 AM | Link to this
Flats, I agree with you on most points. I do agree - Brooke simply sucks. I think Syesha has a good voice, I just don’t think it works well for AI. I believe she could be very successful on Broadway.
As for this season of AI being touted as the best group of contestants ever - B/S. They were all mediocre from the get-go. DC has been the most consistent and has always been the most talented. MJ seemed to find his niche before he left.
The Braves… well, I hear Smoltz is hurt, yet again. As for that other pitcher who hasn’t played in 4 years and still gets paid, I would make him the water boy. If I was paying him that kind of money, he would be working for me in some capacity! Chipper may be hot, but the first time he breaks a nail, he will be on the disabled list. I would put him in a pair of silk panties and a skirt. I go to every Braves home game on the weekends, and usually it is just painful. I also think if the pitcher thinks he is going to walk a batter, he should hit him! If you are going to get a free pass to first base from me, you’re going to do it limping!
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 9:49 AM | Link to this
Agree, JT! I think Simon did it on purpose. She pretty clearly outsang at least 3 other contestants so…either Simon was ‘experimenting’ with his power or he’s as loony as Paula.
By Mia
April 30, 2008 9:53 AM | Link to this
Fire Paula! What an idiot. I voted for Syesha and David C. and I hope Archie does goe home followed by Brooke and Castro.
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 30, 2008 9:59 AM | Link to this
LOL D….or both?
Syesha has a beautiful voice when she isn’t trying to sing “big” (i.e., screaming) … and regardless of how she does on AI, i think there’s definitely a broaday/musical theatre future for her… she may have to start “off broadway” or with touring companies, but i think she has the “stuff” to make it big eventually. But then, both Jennifer and Fantasia made huge jumps, lol, so who knows!
Syesha has the looks, the acting talent (so far as i have seen it) and a beautiful voice. she’ll be fine. I DO agree, however, with the assessment that she hasn’t QUITE found her point of connection with the “world”.
Brooke, on the other hand, has a beautiful voice and style, but it’s extremely limited in scope and appeal.
Cook, on the other hand, has grown from the sort of awkward looking guy to quite a performer in both style and performance. He’s a winner, whether he wins the SHOW or not.
Archie…has reached his adolescent limitations. After his voice completely changes and he matures (IF dad lets him) he may turn out to be quite a nice singer. THink Andy Williams
By azcat225
April 30, 2008 10:04 AM | Link to this
Another lurker emerging from the shadows, at least for the moment. Saw very little of the show last night (life intruded) but David A was horrible on Sweet Caroline. I felt myself cringing at times.
Main reason for my post—-What is it with the new national sport called Paula bashing? Up front, I admit I’m biased, been a fan of hers since wayyyyy back in the 80’s. But, with all that she’s gone through, the physical injuries, the addictions (which she obviously is still battling), to remain as positive as she is, I absolutely admire her and wish only the best for her. She should be offered a hand up, not the back of a hand.
Reminds me of the old saying when I was a kid (and that’s even further back in time)—-“Why don’t you pick on somebody your own size?”
And please save any and all bile directed at me about Paula; insults and attempted intimidation lack any persuasive power.
David Cook all the way!
This concludes the post from another lurker.
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 30, 2008 10:10 AM | Link to this
azcat! meow! [translation: welcome to the mushblog]
seriously glad you dropped in from the lurking station! while i have to agree, Paula’s been through a lot… she makes it really really easy to pick on her, because she IS truly spaceeeee. I think she’s a doll, and i give her great kudos for trying to continue a normal life (well “normal” being relative to hollyweird vs. the rest of the world, but yhou know what i mean) … but azcat, anyone who puts herself in the public eye and then acts a little spacy will have to just accept the attention that follows. it would be unrealistic to NOT comment on it, frankly.
regardless, please “un-lurk” again sometime and join us!!! you know we want all KINDS of voices out here!!!
and yes…DC all the way!!!
By woodpappy
April 30, 2008 10:11 AM | Link to this
Enjoyed reading all you guys takes on last night. Especially Negs, Mike S., Deidre’s, Linny’s, WE and Flats….sorry if I missed someone. I felt the whole thing was rushed way too fast, you couldn’t sit down and enjoy the songs..Oh well, just my thoughts
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 10:15 AM | Link to this
I gotta disagree on Brooke. She has a nice voice but her range can’t be more than an octave and a half(if that’s possible). I’m a Believer started way too low and didn’t hit it’s stride until the end when she stepped up an octave. If she sticks to simple songs, maybe even children’s songs, she’s good but whenever she tries to stretch a little, it’s a disaster.
Syesha has a pretty good range when she doesn’t scream. Her voice is pleasant and her delivery is excellent. She has managed to fit relatively comfortably into all the genres with only a couple of ‘just plain bad’ nights.
That being said..IMO, Brooke is far and away better than the nightmare that Jason has become. Not only does he have almost no range at all…his style fits into a tiny little cubby-hole of music. There’s nowhere for him to go other than where he is right now. And watching him slouch and nod and grimace last night convinced me that he doesn’t care and is not willing to make any kind of an effort.
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 10:18 AM | Link to this
L, I agree about Archie’s future, but I really think he is being groomed to be David Foster’s next “discovery.” Foster has hitched his wagon to Josh Groban’s star and gotten quite a lot out of it. When he was on the show this season, he fawned over Archie. I think that no matter whether DA wins or loses, he is going into the David Foster camp for rising young male singers.
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 10:21 AM | Link to this
Deirdre, I agree with what you said about Jason, but if you hadn’t included his name in that post, it could have applied to Archie as well.
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 30, 2008 10:21 AM | Link to this
woodpappy… the rushed feeling was definitely annoying. It WOULDN’T have been so rushed feeling, i think, if Ryan had just shut up except to say “Syesha [or whoever] next” and “we’ll be right back” … i will certainly never miss the words “After The Break” if i never HEARD them again, and Fox’s shows are particularly BAD about it (5th grader, Lyrics, AI, SYTYCD, yada yada)
And whatEVER made Ryan change directions midstream (literally) to ask the judges their thoughts instead of waiting, AS WAS ANNOUNCED he would do, until BOTH songs were sung by each contestant… i’d have been confused too, and i don’t have any good drugs in my system! sheesh. I did however, appreciate Simon’s rather tongue-in-cheek response after paula’s gaffe… a one-two punch to each of the 5 with no commentary, LOL.
if they’d just announced each person, let him or her sing, then announce the next, it would have seemed ALMOST like a mini concert… just my thoughts… ~¿@
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 30, 2008 10:25 AM | Link to this
True harrietth, DA’s future may be exactly that. But I think that even Foster may find he’s bitten off more than he can chew. DA’s YOUTHFUL amazing talent isn’t translating so well to the adult world. And while the teeny girls may love him…. if he’s not careful, he’ll become just one of a gazillion pretty little boys who can sing nicely enough but… star quality? i dunno, dawg. it’s just aight to me, i mean, dude, you know—just aight.
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 10:27 AM | Link to this
Hello to azcat225 and woodpappy!
azcat….no bile cuz I kind of agree with you…up to a point. Paula is the softer side of the judging and, because of that, she needs to stay.
She clearly said last night before everything started getting weird, that she wasn’t used to critiquing from notes…and it obviously threw her for a loop. And those notes were clearly from the dress rehearsal because, as Lara said earlier, Simon cannot keep his hands off her during the show.
However, speaking of loopy, it was totally irresponsible of her to not organize those notes in a way that would make critiquing easier. She completely……well, FUBAR comes to mind. She walked herself into this trouble and I think it’s going to take a miracle for her to get out of it. She confirmed what a lot of people have been thinking about her.
woodpappy…I thought the show was rushed, too but I like it moving faster(maybe not THAT fast) than slower.
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 10:27 AM | Link to this
D, you are right. Jason does not make any effort. In fact, that is exactly what is troubling about him. The others seem to take the critcism to heart and try to improve. No matter what is suggested to him, he is still the same—no effort to get better or choose better songs.
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 10:29 AM | Link to this
linny, I think Foster’s gonna try anyway. And, yeah, dawg, aight is right. And, he will have to “bite off” David’s father, too, should he decide to accept the assignment. LOL.
By War Eagle
April 30, 2008 10:31 AM | Link to this
For anyone that questions why some of thinks Paula is an idiot, watch it one more time.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mzVGKJ4tgkU
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 30, 2008 10:35 AM | Link to this
^5 harrietth! LOL!!
By azcat225
April 30, 2008 10:37 AM | Link to this
Last post for now (back to work, Mega Millions let me down again..).
Thx for the welcome, Linny. :-)
Yes, Paula is a public figure but it seems nowadays like the public takes enormous pleasure in ripping people to shreds. There has always been the “build ‘em up to tear ‘em down” thing going on, but the nastiness factor has gone off the scale lately. Miley Cyrus comes to mind; I just hope one bad choice doesn’t ruin her life. Nuff of that…
Totally agree with another poster about Jason. No effort, no emotion. He looks like he hit the boredom wall about three shows ago and that there are numerous places he would rather be than still being on AI. A real shame, considering what this opportunity could mean to him.
Happy hump day to all.
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 10:38 AM | Link to this
I was getting to Archie, Dawn…you knew I would! :-)
As for Archie….this is a really talented kid….but ‘kid’ is the operative word. He’s still so childlike that it’s difficult to see him doing anything that doesn’t involve Disney or Nickelodeon. I really like his clear voice but he doesn’t seem able to use it for anything other than high or loud notes. His foggy voice is expressionless and almost atonal. It puts me to sleep. It’s like there’s a humming sound under his words.
David Cook…I admit to not liking him that much at the beginning. But he’s definitely grown on me as time has passed. He has a strong and versatile voice and has proven that he can sing just about anything as long as it can be molded into his style. His straight-up version of Music of the Night was the turning point for me. He’s talented enough, that if he has to, he can sing a song the way it was written and make it interesting and, more importantly, moving.
That’s my top 5 analysis and I’m sticking to it! :-)
By mackpod
April 30, 2008 10:51 AM | Link to this
Show is rigged to give little Archie the win. When will they allow idol hopefuls to sing something from this century!
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 10:57 AM | Link to this
mackpod, that is what everyone thought about Archie on Star Search. I loved, loved, him on that show. But, it was because he was a little kid, eleven or twelve years old, with this incredibly mature voice. No matter. He lost anyway, even though I thought he clearly outperformed the girl who won. This time, his competition—DC—outperforms him, and he is no longer a little kid with an enormous voice. He is an awkward teenager with a voice that is still finding itself. I love his voice most of the time, but he needs to grow up a lot. Does not deserve to be the AI.
By Lara
April 30, 2008 11:19 AM | Link to this
I too felt the rush of everything on the show last night. Perhaps, if they let the contestants sing a version of the song that is longer than 1 minute 15 seconds, they could only do one performance and really do a song justice? I mean, the 2 song thing gives them a chance to show 2 sides, but maybe that should wait until top 3 or 4?
By mvt
April 30, 2008 11:20 AM | Link to this
I have been a DC fan from the start. He has stood out in front every week IMO but it seems lots of folk have felt the same way. I agree with Deirdra about the rest! I watched Paula again when WE sent that link…what to say?? tatally had no clue!
By linny ,,,=^..^=,,,
April 30, 2008 11:27 AM | Link to this
well one thing is for certain — tonight should be interesting insofar as someone going home — will it be a given and Jason, or perhaps Brooke, has finally used up their luck? or will it be a shocker? will adults be gnashing teeth and pulling hair, or will the teenyboppers be screaming epithets at the ol’ tube?
find out…. after the…. oh nevermind!
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 11:32 AM | Link to this
LOL! linny!
I know what I’m hoping for but so far, my luck has been very poor when it comes to picking who will go home!
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 11:38 AM | Link to this
Who is Foster and Monchichi
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 11:46 AM | Link to this
Dawn…Foster is a music producer.
Monchichi is MikeS’ name for Archie.
By flats
April 30, 2008 11:47 AM | Link to this
Eagle….What’s up?
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 11:48 AM | Link to this
Um…does the blog look ‘weird’ to anyone else? All the comments are in ‘bold type’ on my computer and much of Rodney’s text has turned blue.
By JTesla
April 30, 2008 11:50 AM | Link to this
Monchichi… classic. DawnH, look it up on wikipedia there is a picture and explanation.
By Lara
April 30, 2008 11:54 AM | Link to this
Deirdre - I am having that same issue.
By flats
April 30, 2008 11:55 AM | Link to this
Mine too D…Hope that doesn’t ruin your day.
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 11:56 AM | Link to this
Dierdre, yes, I see what you are seeing.
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 11:59 AM | Link to this
Thanks, Lara…I always like to know that it’s not just my computer! Maybe they’re upgrading the format…..maybe pigs can fly…maybe hell will freeze over…
By Karen
April 30, 2008 12:02 PM | Link to this
I’m loving David Cook. sigh!
Anyhow, I think Syesha did well. I think its Brooke or Jason’s turn to go. Even though, Jason’s first song was pretty good.
Did ya hear Paula on Q100 this morning? They did change the program up on them last night. I can understand her getting somewhat confused.
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 12:05 PM | Link to this
Good…I’m not just seeing things…thought I was suffering from Abdul syndrome where the future appears before my eyes but nobody else can see it!
By War Eagle
April 30, 2008 12:06 PM | Link to this
what’s up flats
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 12:08 PM | Link to this
Thanks everyone for the explanation. My type is weird too
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 12:10 PM | Link to this
Karen…didn’t know Paula was on Q100 this morning. I figured something had changed. The director probably told Ryan he had a minute and a half to fill and he asked for general impressions. Still Paula wasn’t giving a general impression, she started giving individual critiques. Like I said earlier, it was FUBAR!
By Copper Tone
April 30, 2008 12:10 PM | Link to this
2 many player haters w/Syesha.She performs and represents darn well.Give the girl her props.Stop the I like U fan club and be real.She’s in the Top 3.Paula is in LaLa land w/her judging(this is not a beauty pagent).She rather make comments about their looks vs.being honest about the performance.Simon sometimes u wonder what he hears.GO Syesha, u will get ur just reward without the jealous haters.
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 12:13 PM | Link to this
I need some help from all of you music afficianados. I have been trying to find a CD - any CD - of Daryl Pediford. All I can find are CDs of a Trans Siberian Orchestra, of which he was a member, and they are all Christmas CDs. Anyone ever heard of this guy and know who might carry his music. I’ve check the few online sites I know. Thanks for the help.
By Copper Tone
April 30, 2008 12:14 PM | Link to this
2 many player haters w/Syesha.She performs and represents darn well.Give the girl her props.Stop the I like U fan club and be real.She’s in the Top 3.Paula is in LaLa land w/her judging(this is not a beauty pagent).She rather make comments about their looks vs.being honest about the performance.Simon sometimes u wonder what he hears.GO Syesha, u will get ur just reward without the jealous haters.
By BeBeCa
April 30, 2008 12:21 PM | Link to this
Hi all, I’ve never commented, but I read the blog regularly. Overall, I’m a little disappointed by this season of AI. I like David Cook to win. I also like Syesha, but she hasn’t had that one performance that makes her stand out. I really don’t like David A., not becuase he isn’t a good singer but I don’t like his style. Jason is boring, and Brooke has good sound, but she isn’t a stronger singer.
Deidre, I tend to agree with your view points! Oh, and pigs can apparently fly… (here)(http://www.entertainment.msn.com/news/article.aspx?news=311909>1=7702).
By flats
April 30, 2008 12:22 PM | Link to this
I just found out a buddy i know down there died this morning.Probally heading down for the funeral.
By BeBeCa
April 30, 2008 12:27 PM | Link to this
I don’t know how to link apparently!
By Captain Herb
April 30, 2008 12:30 PM | Link to this
No doubt that Perky Paula is the weakest link, even before last night’s debacle and one week removed from her telling Brooke that you just can’t forget the lyrics. Who should replace Paula?
L’il Kim? Wynonna Judd? Chaka Khan? Toni Braxton? Courtney Love?
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 12:33 PM | Link to this
Sorry Flats.
By harrietth
April 30, 2008 12:38 PM | Link to this
DawnH, try looking up Papa Jazz in Columbia, SC and Horizon Records in Greenville, SC. They both have websites and usually carry the “off the beaten path” stuff. Sorry. I have been out of Atlanta for too many years to be current about shops there.
By War Eagle
April 30, 2008 12:39 PM | Link to this
Sorry about your buddy flats.
By Menana
April 30, 2008 12:52 PM | Link to this
After reading all the posts,oh where do I start?
First, I have only one statement about Paula - She seemed incoherent due to some stage of inebriation.
Now to the show and contestants. I too felt it was to rushed. Don’t ever remember a show being this rushed before. I’m sure that Ryan had the judges make their comments after the first songs as he was told by the producers. That would put anyone on the spot if they weren’t expecting it at that moment.
I really feel sorry for Syesha. As posted earlier, she is the least favorite of the judges for whatever reason, esp for Simon. I, for one, really like her and voted for her several times last night. I would like to see a DC and Syesha finale. But with the fan base that little David has, that most likely will not be. Maybe they will be the top three.
Jason is SO NOT into AI. He is, IMO, very lackadaisical and gives off the attitude that he doesn’t give one iota if he stays or goes. What the judges or mentors say to him seems to be irrelevant to him. He has one style and he sticks with it
As far as Brooke goes, there isn’t much that I can add to what all has already been said. She at least, does take to heart what the judges and mentors advise her.
We certainly do not need another shocker tonight with no one other than Jason going home. Do I hear an AMEN to him going?
By DawnH
April 30, 2008 12:54 PM | Link to this
harrieth - thanks so much. I sent both emails to see if such a CD even exists. Appreciate it!
By Nick
April 30, 2008 1:10 PM | Link to this
Paula needs to stop “partying” with Whitney. Doesn’t she know that “crack is whack”!
By Carri
April 30, 2008 1:50 PM | Link to this
HELLOOO…MCFLYYY… Simon is using REVERSE PSYCHOLOGY when it comes to judging Syesha so she can get more “pity votes”. I don’t think he has it in for her at all. I also think that is what they are all doing with Archie - just the opposite, so people don’t go overboard voting for him. Personally, I don’t really care about any of them anymore, except David Cook. He should be the winner. Everyone else is sad and boring. NO ONE this season has an exceptional voice (like Melinda Doolittle).
By heybud
April 30, 2008 2:21 PM | Link to this
Poor, poor Paula. I felt sorry for her last night. Not only did she mess up the impromptu comments after each contestant had sung their first song, I too heard her call Syesha, Brooke.
To be honest I was not particualarly impressed with anyone’s performance last night. As Simon would say, they were all pretty “forgetable”, but here are my rankings by contestant:
David Cook
David Archuleta
Syesha Mercado
Brooke White
Jason Castro
By Deirdre
April 30, 2008 2:32 PM | Link to this
BeBeCa…sorry, I was out running some errands when you posted….don’t worry, I don’t know how to link either. Hang around!
I see there’s a new thread up so I’ll be hanging out over there.
By Blkshepherd
April 30, 2008 3:29 PM | Link to this
Boring, Boring, Boring. I dont blame Paula for having a few. What a lame season. At this point none of them is worthy of the crown. There is no Clay, no Fantasia, no ruben..no kelly not even a Taylor Hicks! Can always tell when a show is beginning to bore me when I leave the room, skip through all the blogs(I have not read one) and actually am with Paula.(not knowing who sang what) Syeasha you just aint like girl, pack your bags. David A..boring..David Cook(smelling himself, whatever)..the dude with the long dreds(why is he still there?) Overall grade..F- Perhaps next season(if I bother to watch, will have some promise)..Whomever wins this season will be like a few past season winners..after Hicks won and Jordin won..who really cares now? gonna have to find me something else to watch on Tues and Wednsdays..AI is fluff.
By David Mac
April 30, 2008 3:41 PM | Link to this
I am getting tired of the judges pandering to the teeny bopper audience. David A. IS TERRIBLE. I am sick of his same old warbling I can’t stand it. With the ouster of Michael and Carly there is only one talent left. David Cook is the next Daughtry. The others have lasted beyond their talent level. DAVID A HAS GOT TO GO!!!!!
By Beell
April 30, 2008 3:55 PM | Link to this
I don’t know what Paula has in that coke glass, but, I’ll have what she’s having !!! she ain’t feelin no pain lol
By tanning lotion
April 30, 2008 9:30 PM | Link to this
Paula is awesome. Not only is she beautiful, but she is a real person. Stick with it Paula.
tanning lotion