The Red Violin
Verdict: A sweeping symphony, with some parts better than others.
Details: Starring Samuel L. Jackson. Directed by Francois Girard. Not rated, but contains nudity and sexuality. 2 hours, 10 minutes.
Review: Francois Girard's best-known movie, 1993's "Thirty-Two Short Films About Glenn Gould," was as
playful, spare and sophisticated as his most recent one, "The Red Violin," is florid, expansive and
emotional.
A centuries-spanning saga, it follows the fortunes and, more often, misfortunes of those who come
into contact with a violin carved in 1681 by an Italian master named Bussotti (Carlo Cecchi).
First, Girard establishes an intriguing framing device. We begin in the present, where, at a chichi
Montreal auction house, a Stradivarius knocked down for $1.9 million is merely the second most
important piece being offered. The "star of the evening," as the auctioneer says, is the so-called Red
Violin, an instrument so perfectly conceived that an expert (Samuel L. Jackson) called in to
authenticate the items has become obsessed with it.
Actually, the auction isn't the only framing device. Skip back three centuries to Italy, where an
ancient servant is reading the tarot cards for her mistress, Anna (Irene Grazioli), Bussotti's very lovely
and very pregnant wife. But is it the woman's future being read--or that of the violin her husband is so
feverishly trying to finish before the birth of their child?
From there, the Red Violin wends its way from hand to hand, from country to country. It finds a
home at a 17th-century Austrian monastery, where it's picked up by an orphaned prodigy. It also
ends up with Gypsies, thieves and between the naked legs of Frederick Pope (Jason Flemyng), a
19th-century British virtuoso whose tempestuous affair with a Victorian author (Greta Scacchi) is one
of the sillier segments. Pope's Chinese manservant (Stuart Ong) returns to his homeland with the
instrument, where, several decades later, the Red Violin collides with Mao's Cultural Revolution
before landing in Montreal, where Jackson finally unravels its tragic secret.
The different stories vary in quality, from the near-sublime (the Italian section) to the ridiculous (the
aforementioned Pope pulp). But the one thing that remains constant is the inherent intrigue of Girard's
central conceit. The Red Violin is as much seeker as sought. There are those through whose hands it
passes without leaving a mark. But there are also those for whom the violin is a destiny in waiting.
Using an inanimate object to tie together a series of short stories was once a hugely popular
construct. In the 1940s, "Tales of Manhattan" followed a tailcoat. In the '60s, it was "The Yellow
Rolls Royce." But underneath this familiar structure, there's a surprising ferocity. The violin's secret
creates, not a curse necessarily, but a fate. It's a bit like Michael Powell's 1948 ballet wonder "The
Red Shoes," a reminder of the unquenchable chaos that flirts with all true artists. To forestall the
outraged e-mail, no, "The Red Violin" is not a masterpiece like "The Red Shoes," but its power
comes from a similar impulse: an attempt to understand the creative/destructive fulcrum in which
artistic genius resides.
"The Red Violin" will be too melodramatic for some tastes, too schematic for others. But anyone
who's ever felt a chill at the revelations of an overturned tarot card will hear this film's inner music.
Eleanor Ringel Gillespie, Cox News Service
[an error occurred while processing this directive] | ||||
Inside AJC.COM
Holiday shopping
Realtime shopping updates for gift bargains in Metro Atlanta. See a deal? Tell everyone!
Weekend Best Bets
International Cat Show, Chante Moore, Magical Night of Lights, chef cook-offs and more!
Obama Inauguration
Travelling to D.C. on Jan. 20? Here's everything you need to know for your planning.
Cheap Travel
No need to drop big bucks. Here are 25 offerings for cruise, hotel and fall travel packages.
Top 5 in Atlanta
Skip those drive-thrus. Here are five of best places in Atlanta for a juicy hamburger.
Christmas House
The 2008 edition, with its garlands and wreaths, benefits Alliance Children's Theater.
From the Blogs
-
Radio & TV Talk
-
Movie Talk
-
Atlanta Music Scene
-
ATL Arts
Table Talk
-
American Idol Buzz
11/21: Phil Stacey loses label deal, Kristy Lee Cook begging for recognition
-
Chatter
Best Bets: Indie Folk, Unusual Gifts and the Return of the "Santaland" Elf
-
Misadventures in Atlanta
-
Peach Buzz
-
Social Butterfly
-
Best of the Big A
-
The Newcomer
Best of the Big A
-
Current nominations
-
Current voting
-
Latest winner
The Red Violin



