'Yes' is alternately annoying and engaging
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
In the wake of Sept. 11, after so many voices screamed no no no, filmmaker Sally Potter decided to respond with a yes. Make that "Yes," her (literally) poetic meditation on love in a time of fear.
Actually her movie is about a lot more to its credit and, sometimes, its detriment. First and foremost, "Yes" is about Joan Allen's translucent skin, birdlike bones, and wearily palpable smarts.
Sony Pictures Classics
B The verdict: A movie told in rhyme, both annoying and sublime. Director: Sally Potter On the web |
||
She plays a woman known only as She (yeah, it's that kind of movie). An Irish-American scientist involved with stem cell research, she's married to no, not He, but a British politician named Anthony (Sam Neill). Nearing the frayed end of their marriage, they share a home but little else besides a tense truce and a housekeeper (Shirley Henderson), who speak to us directly from the screen, spilling their secrets.
As for He (Simon Abkarian), he's a Lebanese surgeon, transplanted from Beirut to London, where his skill with a knife can only get him work as a restaurant cook.
He and She meet at a lavishly dull political banquet he's working, where she's the only guest with as much light as shadow in her smile. He tells her, "I'd like to steal/ You from the man who cannot see/ That you're a queen."
Oh, did I mention that the dialogue is written in rhyming couplets? Like many of the ideas in "Yes," the gimmick is alternately annoying and engaging. It's what you expect from a risk-taker like Potter, best known for the gender-bending "Orlando" (1992) (in which she cast Quentin Crisp as Queen Elizabeth I).
As He and She embark on an affair in "Yes," we start to note their differences. A Muslim, He sees the world as a place of mystery and faith. Her faith, as a lapsed Catholic, resides in science and observable phenomena. They're a study in opposites. Like the movie.
"Yes" could've been titled "The Poetry of Oppositions." Potter sets up a wealth of contrasts and lets them bang together: man/woman, East/West, faith/disbelief, Islam/Christianity, rich/poor, passion/control, individuality/national identity, etc.
The movie doesn't just wear its politics on its shirtsleeves, its politics are its shirtsleeves. And pants. And underwear, too. At one point, the lovers frolic in the tropical surf of Cuba "a great big dream that's fallen pretty flat," in the words (or thoughts, anyway) of the woman's revolutionary-minded auntie, on her deathbed in Belfast.
"Yes" is about the rise and fall of such dreams, the mistakes people make for all the right reasons, and the daily struggle to see one another clearly when history and cultural prejudices try to blind us. It's a movie as sophisticated as it sometimes is naive.
Even if you're sympathetic to some of Potter's ideas, the filmmaker can sabotage herself. That beach sequence, for instance, is kitsch better suited to the cover of a romance novel. And Potter swamps some scenes with slo-mo/stutter camera effects that call attention to themselves in a movie whose entry-level artificiality makes you work that much harder to suspend your disbelief.
Take, for instance, that rhyming dialogue. While technically skillful, it sometimes trips incomprehensibly off the actors' tongues especially in the monologues by the mournfully liquid-eyed, squeaky-voiced Henderson.
These lapses are ameliorated by other moments, like a frosty dinner exchange between Allen and Neill, or Allen and Abkarian's explosive argument in a parking garage. The actors are so committed to Potter's vision, they persuade you to go along with them. To go along, to seize the day, to love, and — even when you sometimes know better — to say yes.
Inside AJC.COM
Beyonce concert review

Watch a video of fans re-enacting their favorite parts of Beyonce's Atlanta concert.
Best of Luckovich: June

Vote for your favorite Mike Luckovich editorial cartoons on local new, politics, celebrities and more!
Ingenuity + yard = fun

Boredom and lack of money are the mothers of invention when it comes to lawn games such as lawn Scrabble.
Romantic vacation tales

Our new travel story contest centers on your most romantic vacation tales. Tell us, lovers.
Private Quarters Splurge

Husband and wife architects created a modern house that's still warm and inviting.
From the Blogs
Best of the Big A
-
Current nominations
Where is the best place to buy shoes in and around Atlanta? -
Current voting
- Where can you get the best breakfast in and around Atlanta?
-
Latest winner
Where is the best place to see 4th of July fireworks in and around Atlanta?

