You can never go wrong with pie, so why not treat yourself to a delicious slice? Whether you want something sweet or savory, traditional pie flavors like apple or pecan, or something a little more adventurous, there are plenty of options to choose from. We want to make it “easy as pie” for you to find the perfect slice in Atlanta, so we’ve listed some of the best spots below.
CHECK OUT: Find your next read at one of these 5 Black-owned bookstores in Atlanta
Southern Baked Pie Company
Since its debut in 2012, Southern Baked Pie Company has been specializing in scrumptious gourmet pies, both sweet and savory, that are ideal for any special occasion. They have a wide variety of flavors, from buttermilk pie and French coconut custard pie to chicken pot pie and caramel pecan pie. Consider signing up for their Pie of the Month Club.
Location: Multiple locations; Website: southernbakedpie.com; Contact: 404-263-0656
Your pie, your way. You can literally build your own pie, step by step, at Doodle Pies. First, you choose your pie filling, then your add-ins, and finally, your toppings. With a simple and quick process, you can make your own hot or cold pie and enjoy your creation in no time!
Location: Roswell - 1105 Woodstock Rd., Suite 140; Website: doodlepies.net; Contact: 678-373-1758
Panbury’s Double Crust Pies
Located inside Sweet Auburn’s Municipal Market, you’ll find Panbury’s serving tasty, made fresh-to-order pies with unforgettable crusts. Inspired by the co-owners’ South African roots, their hearty and flavorful hand pies will keep you full and satisfied.
RELATED: Your guide to Atlanta’s historic Sweet Auburn neighborhood
Location: Downtown - 209 Edgewood Ave. SE, Suite #104; Website: panburys.com; Contact: 404-500-1279
At Pie Bar, there are many sweet and savory pie choices to enjoy. Struggle to pick just one flavor? You can choose to order a complete pie with two different flavors by selecting their “half and half” option. Make sure to try their refreshing Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Pop made in collaboration with King of Pops.
Location: Two locations (Woodstock and Marietta); Website: orderpiebar.com
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
When you need to satisfy your sweet tooth, stop by Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Sandy Springs and try one of their many indulgent Southern pies. With flavors like chocolate cream, key lime, apple, peanut butter cream, chewy chocolate chip and more, this place just might become one of your favorites.
Location: Sandy Springs - 4600 Roswell Rd.; Website: buttermilkskypie.com; Contact: 404-975-3822
Aunt Evelyn’s Peach Cobbler
Taking inspiration from her South Georgia roots and her grandmother’s delightful homemade cobblers, Aunt Evelyn’s is a must-try if you’re looking for an old-fashioned peach cobbler. The incredible crust and fresh, homemade taste will leave you wanting more. Other flavors include blueberry and apple.
Location: East Atlanta - 1642 McLendon Ave. NE; Website: auntevelynspeachcobbler.com; Contact: 877-577-9933
Sally’s Gluten Free Bakery
For those seeking gluten free pies (and other desserts), look no further than Sally’s Gluten-Free Bakery, which has three convenient locations in the Atlanta area. Both their pumpkin pie and pecan pie are holiday staples worth indulging in all year.
Location: Multiple locations (North Druid Hills, Sandy Springs and Alpharetta); Website: sallysglutenfreebakery.com
The Pie Hole
Located in downtown Roswell, The Pie Hole sells freshly prepared homemade pies every day. You can order some of their amazing savory and sweet flavors, including French silk, chicken pot pie, s’mores and cherry.
Location: Roswell - 1025 Canton St.; Website: openyourpiehole.com; Contact: 678-461-3776
Sweet Auburn Bread Company
This family-owned bakery offers sweet treats including cheesecake, pies and pound cakes if you’re looking for some fantastic local desserts. They are famous for their incredible sweet potato pie as well as their Southern pecan pie and buttermilk lemon chess.
Location: Downtown - 234 Auburn Ave. NE; Website: sweetauburnbread.com; Contact: 404-805-7992
Flour and Time
For a plant-based indulgence, check out Flour and Time to enjoy some of their delicious vegan pies and other baked goods. You will truly enjoy this all-vegan spot with flavors like veggie sausage pot pie, apple pie, key lime pie and pecan pie.
Location: Avondale Estates - 121 Center St.; Website: flourandtimebakery.com; Contact: 470-707-4626
Crave Pie Studio
With fresh, seasonal ingredients and an all-butter flaky crust, Crave Pie Studio features everything from fruit pies and nut pies, to cream, custard, chess and pot pies. These hand-crafted artisan pies are jam-packed with flavor and provide an outstanding variety of different options to choose from. Whether you’re looking for banana cream, maple pecan, lemon meringue, or anything else in between, you can certainly find it at Crave.
Location: Two locations (Duluth and Alpharetta); Website: cravepie.com